PUR vs Brita Water Filters
TL;DR PUR vs Brita Water Filters
Both Brita and PUR are well-established, trusted brands that make a variety of filtration products. When comparing their best water pitcher filters, the Brita Everyday and the PUR Classic, we chose the PUR Classic to be the better filter because of its higher number of contaminants removed and the higher capacity.
We found that both pitchers perform similarly when it comes to filtration rate, cost, and customer reviews, and the Everyday does slightly better with durability and filter replacement. On the other hand, the Classic is easier to clean and has more features, and is certified for an extra standard from NSF.
|Brita Everyday||PUR Classic|
|Most Contaminants Removed||✓|
|Fast Filtration Rate||✓||✓|
|NSF and WQA Certified||✓||✓|
|Easiest to Clean||✓|
|Great Customer Reviews||✓||✓|
PUR vs Brita Filters Overview
PUR, formerly named Recovery Engineering, was founded in 1986 and has since produced high-quality filters for water pitchers and faucets as well as water dispensers. Brita, on the other hand, has been around since 1966 and has put their 50 years of experience to good use making filters for water pitchers, dispensers, faucets, and water bottles.
In order to compare apples to apples, we chose a water pitcher filter from each brand to represent them and compared them on key qualities like contaminants filtered, lifespan, capacity, and others. Our choice for the best water pitcher filter from PUR is their PUR Classic Water Filter Pitcher, while our choice from Brita is the Brita Everyday Water Filter Pitcher.
Dimensions and Capacity
We think the PUR pitcher has a slight edge here as well as a good looking design.
Both the Standard and the Longlast filters use granulated activated carbon from coconut fiber to remove heavy mercury as well as foul tastes and odors, with a mesh screen to filter black flecks. The Standard filter has an ion exchange resin that reduces heavy metals, while the Longlast has a pleated media as well as proprietary active filtering agents that works on lead and other contaminants.
PUR also offers two different filter types: the Faster filter and the filter with lead reduction. Both use MAXION filter technology, which similar to Brita uses blended activated carbon and ion exchange materials. MAXION filters remove heavy metals, foul tastes and odors, industrial pollutants, and pharmaceuticals, and the main differences between the two PUR filters are the lead reduction capability and their lifespan.
We think the PUR takes a slight edge again with the ability for lead reduction and slightly more contaminants removed.
Brita’s Everyday pitcher has been certified for NSF/ANSI standards 42 and 53. Standard 42 refers to the aesthetic improvement of water by removing foul tastes and odors, while standard 53 means that heavy metals with negative health consequences have been adequately filtered.
PUR’s Classic pitcher has also been certified for NSF/ANSI standards 42 and 53, as well as standard 401. This standard means that the filter reduces emerging compounds with potential health benefits such as Atenolol and Estrone.
Overall, they both match up the same in certifications.
|Brita Standard||Brita Longlast||PUR Faster MAXION||PUR MAXION with Lead Reduction|
|Pesticides and Herbicides||✓||✓|
As far as heavy metals go, the Brita Standard filter works to remove up to 94% of copper, 96% of mercury, and 96% of cadmium. It also removes 95% of chlorine and 64% of zinc – the main culprits behind foul odors and tastes. The Brita Longlast works on the same contaminants as the Standard while also removing 99% of lead and the organic and industrial pollutants benzene, asbestos, and BPA. The Longlast also works on the pharmaceuticals ibuprofen and naproxen.
In comparison, both the Faster MAXION and the MAXION with lead reduction remove up to 98.2% of copper, 96.7% of mercury, and 98.7% of cadmium, as well as 97.5% of chlorine and 86.9% of zinc. They also remove 99.99% of microbial cysts, and the pesticides/herbicides 2,4-D (86%), Atrazine (82.7%), Linuron (96.1%) and Simazine (97.1%).
Both PUR filters also remove industrial chemicals, with 96.4% of benzene, 96% of carbon tetrachloride, 96.6% of tetrachloroethylene, 94.2% of TCEP, 94.2% of BPA, and 95.9% of nonyl phenol removed as well as the pharmaceuticals atenolol (94.3%), carbamazepine (94.3%), estrone (96.1%), and trimethoprim (96.2%). The lead reduction filter is rated for up to 99.4% lead removal.
The bottom line is that MAXION filtration removes higher quantities of more contaminants. The only contaminants that the Brita Longlast removes that the MAXION ones don’t are asbestos, ibuprofen, and naproxen
Having said that, if your water only has chlorine and copper in it you’re going to get a similar performance from both brands’ filters. Whether you need the extra filtration capacity of the PUR filters depends on what contaminants are in your water – and you can purchase a water testing kit to get a breakdown of your water’s contents. If you would rather not test and just cover your bases, the PUR filter is going to be the best.
The Classic comes with a built-in handle and a spout to make pouring easy, and the filter compartment is built into the lid of the pitcher. To replace the filter, you unscrew the old one and screw the new one back in.
The Brita Everyday pitcher also has a built-in handle and pouring spout for ease of use, and the filter is similarly built into a compartment in the lid. You swap out filters by simply pulling the old one out of the slot and pushing the new one into the groove.
Unlike the PUR Classic’s indicator, the Everyday pitcher has a sticker with the recommendations for filter changing and a mini-calendar where you can mark when your filter needs to be replaced for the next two years.
We think the PUR lighting technology is more advanced in this department.
Likewise, the reviews for both the Brita Standard and Longlast filters say that they take roughly five minutes to run water through the filter. Changing the filters for both brands as recommended will help make sure the filtration rate remains fast. It’s also worth noting that it takes multiple fill-ups of the filter to completely fill both the Everyday and the Classic pitchers.
Both brands have pretty much the same filtration speed.
Filter Lifespan and Pitcher Durability
In comparison, the Brita Standard filter comes with the pitcher and will last for 1-2 months or 40 gallons, once again depending on your usage. As the name would suggest, the Brita Longlast filter can last up to 6 months or 120 gallons before needing to be replaced.
As for the pitchers themselves, both the PUR Classic and the Brita Everyday come with a 90 day warranty. Reviews for the PUR Classic mostly agreed that the pitcher will last for at least a year before the plastic cracks, and the Brita Everyday reviews had many positive comments on the durability of the product.
The PUR pitcher filter change indicator runs off of a sealed battery that is not replaceable without buying a new pitcher, so if your pitcher ends up lasting several years you may eventually lose your indicator light. In both filter lifespan (for the Longlast) and durability, Brita has the edge.
For the Brita Everyday filter, the initial price is $27.99 which includes the pitcher, the filter housing, and a Brita Standard filter. As for the replacement filters, you can get a single one of the Standard filters for $6.58, or if you’d rather stockpile you can get 3, 4, 5, 6, or even 10 filters for $35.99 (the best value). The Longlast filter is available as a single filter for $16.99, or as a 2-pack for $32.99.
On the other hand, the PUR Classic filter is $29.99 which likewise includes the pitcher and filter housing as well as the PUR Faster MAXION filter. You can get a single Faster filter replacement for $6.99, or a 3-pack for $16.99. The MAXION filter with lead reduction is $10.99 for a single filter, or $24.99 for a 3-pack.
The costs are pretty similar for both brands give or take a few dollars.
Costs Over Time
If you wanted to use the lead reduction filter, let’s say you’ll need to replace it five times since it has a slightly higher gallon rating than the Faster filter. You can get two 3-packs for $25 each, and that will put you at $80 for the year including the pitcher – and you’ll have a filter left over for your next change.
As for the Brita Everyday, you’ll spend $28 on the pitcher and the included Standard filter will likewise last for two months. You’ll need to replace it five times over the course of the year, and you can conveniently get a 5-pack for $22. For a year with the standard filter, you’re looking at $50.
If you decide to go with the Longlast filter, you’ll need to swap out the included standard filter after two months and then you won’t need a new Longlast filter until eight months later. You can get two single filters for $22, or a 3-pack for $25 so you’ll save some money on future replacements. At the end of the year, you’ll have either spent $50 or $53 with the pitcher.
Types of Models Each Company Offers
They also make a Basic model without the LED filter change indicator that only comes with the Basic filter, which removes the same contaminants as the Faster filter but has a slower filtration rate. The Basic model is not compatible with the other filters, however.
The last of PUR’s pitcher models is the Ultimate, which takes the same filters as the Classic. The main difference with the Ultimate pitcher is its design and durability. Similar to the pitchers are PUR’s dispensers, which have an 18-cup capacity and use a nozzle to dispense water when pressed. You can get the dispenser with a Basic filter, a Faster filter, or a lead reduction filter, but the basic model is likewise not compatible with the others.
PUR also offers a line of faucet filters that incorporate their branded MineralClear filtration. These filters remove 72+ contaminants, and there are two models available for purchase: the Advanced Faucet Filtration System and the Ultimate Faucet Filtration System with Bluetooth.
Brita also makes a line of water dispensers with two different models: the Ultramax and the Ultraslim. The Ultramax has an 18 cup capacity while the Ultraslim can hold up to 25, and they both use a nozzle dispensing system as well. Both will fit either the Standard or Longlast filters.
You can also find two different faucet filters from Brita: the Basic Faucet Mount System and the Complete Faucet Mount System. Both take Brita’s Faucet Mount filter, which filters out 60 different contaminants, and the main difference between the two is the filter lifespan indicator on the Complete.
Unlike PUR, Brita also makes a line of water bottle filters that come in four different sizes: 20oz, 26oz, 32oz, and 36oz. Unlike the other filters, the bottle filters only remove contaminants that cause foul tastes and odors.
Customer Reviews and Complaints
In comparison, the Brita Everyday has 24,042 reviews with a 4.7 out of 5 star rating and 81% 5-star reviews. 12% are 4-star and 4% are 3-star. Only 2% of revives are 1-star and 1% 2-star, which gives Everyday the edge on both the quantity and quality of reviews.
The main negative reviews for the Everyday pitcher are that it’s difficult to clean, which predisposes it to mildew and algae growth. The other main complaints are that the customers didn’t notice a change in the taste of their water, and that Brita wouldn’t take returns.
Pros and Cons
Brita Everyday Pros
Contaminants removed: Both the Standard and Longlast filters remove heavy metals like cadmium, mercury, and copper as well as elements that cause foul taste and odor like zinc and chlorine. The Longlast filter also works on some industrial chemicals and pharmaceuticals as well as lead.
Certification: This product has been NSF certified for standards 53 and 42, as well as WQA certified.
Filtration rate: Both the Standard and the Longlast take about five minutes to filter through a full round of water.
Filter lifespan: The Longlast filter lives up to its name with the six-month lifespan, which is three times as long as the other filters on the market.
Price: The Everyday is a very reasonably-priced water pitcher filter, and the costs over time are low as well no matter whether you go with the Standard or Longlast filter replacements.
Customer reviews: With 81% 5-star reviews on over 24,000 ratings, people love their Brita Everyday filters.
Brita Everyday Cons
Ease of cleaning: Many customers complained that the pitcher and filter holder are difficult to clean, and some as a result saw mildew or algae growth.
Product features: Unlike many of Brita’s other pitcher models, the Everyday does not have an electric indicator for the filter lifespan.
PUR Classic Pros
Contaminants removed: Both PUR MAXION filters remove 22 different contaminants from heavy metals to pesticides to industrial chemicals, and the lead reduction filter also removes 99% of lead.
Certifications: This product has been WQA certified as well as NSF certified for standards 42, 53, and 401.
Filtration rate: Both the Faster filter and the lead-reduction filter take about five minutes to work for each fill.
Price: The level of water filtration for the price is unbeatable, and the replacement filters are reasonable.
Customer reviews: PUR satisfies the vast majority of their customers with 75% 5-star reviews on over 4,500 ratings.
PUR Classic Cons
Durability: One of the main customer complaints was that the plastic of the pitcher tends to be brittle.
Filter lifespan: PUR does not offer a filter that lasts for more than 2 months.
Both the Brita Everyday and the PUR Classic model water pitcher filters are excellent products that will bring quality water to your household. The PUR Classic filter removes more contaminants and has an indicator for changing the filter, while the Brita Everyday is more durable and has a filter with a longer lifespan.
If your water has a high number of contaminants, you’re better off going with the PUR Classic. If your water requires only aesthetic improvement or has very little contaminants, either pitcher will deliver great water.